Mar 142013
 

Sarah-Maize2Every parent has lived with a pet she did not want. In my case, it was an albino corn snake named Maize.

Maize was beautiful as snakes go with a lovely pattern in shades of deep rose, coral, and salmon. She was small at first and adorable as creatures are in infancy. She belonged to my daughter, who became a vegetarian and a reptile enthusiast in her freshman year of college. Maize traveled to and from school in a plastic box carrier.

Then came the semester my daughter matriculated in Ecuador, and Maize came to live with me. While my daughter sent home photos of her playing with boa constrictors in the rain forest, I was buying pinkies at the local pet store. Pinkies are Maize’s preferred meal. They are one-day-old, hairless, dead mice babies kept in a brown bag in my freezer. They look like pink embryos next to the ice cream and frozen peas.

One thing I knew from the moment I became a parent: I would go to great lengths for my children. Just like in my novel Book of Mercy, where parents censor books, for the sake of the children. They get into fights with their spouses, for the sake of the children. They throw pies, for the sake of the children. They reveal deep, dark secrets, for the sake of the children.

On the back cover of Mercy, it says, “There are more things worth fighting for than you can ever imagine.” One of the things we fight, for the sake of our children, is ourselves. You see, I (for no good reason) fear snakes. When I meet a snake on the hiking trail, it is like a scene from a cartoon—we both leap up and run (or wiggle) in the opposite direction. But there I was, during that long semester, dropping frozen mice snacks into Maize’s cage and, because my daughter insisted, taking Maize out for the occasional exercise.

I never fell in love with the experience of slowly lifting Maize from its cage and letting it wind its way around my body. Still, I turned my body into a snake’s playground because I certainly wasn’t going to let it loose in the house. Do you know how fast those suckers can get away from you? And then, I’d live in true terror of waking up one morning with Maize curled in my hair.

I took on a snake for a housemate, for my kid. That’s what parents do.

Memories of Maize came back this week for two reasons: I spotted a snake on a Facebook page that looked just like Maize; it was wearing a pink sweater. The same day, I saw a comic of a snake reading a book titled “Anyone Can Knit.” Ahh, if only that were true. One of my dreams has always been to sit in my cozy, snake-free house and knit something more intricate than a potholder, like maybe a Bill Cosby/Cliff Huxtable sweater.

____________________________

If you would like to read how parents stay sane while their child studies abroad, click here.

Have you lived with a pet you didn’t want? Leave a comment.

Dec 112012
 

After several excruciating hours navigating the mass mileage of the Mall of America, I lug my Christmas bags home, plop down in a chair, and realize with sadness: I don’t know how to do it right anymore. Christmas shopping, that is. I have an indescribable urge to wail for my mother.

Not that the shopping was that good in the small Missouri town where I grew up. In fact, if an alien spaceship took me up into the skies, transporting my molecules (in a friendly manner) from here in Minnesota to there, I probably would find myself on foreign ground. I understand most of the people in my hometown don’t shop there anymore; they do not search the quiet stores downtown in the twilight. They drive to Walmart out by the interstate or trek thirty miles down the road to one of the bigger burgs on the Mississippi River, a place powdered with shopping malls and discount houses. From the portals of a spaceship, I bet it looks just like every other town in America.

When I was young and without wheels, a driver’s license, or a credit card, I knew how to shop. I would choose a December afternoon, inform my mother I was walking downtown after school, and stuff in my pocket $1.69 for each member of my family. The amount never left my head as I circled the courthouse square, studying the windows of the hardware store, the jeweler, the dime store, the drug store, and the department store. Would my mother like that beautiful little bejeweled box? Does my father need a new screwdriver? And of lesser concern: what would bring my little sisters happiness?

Those afternoons of Yuletide bliss were moments of glorious freedom and joy, the kind that wells up in your heart and sends it tripping with happiness. Although I am sure the town square was busier than usual due to the season, I do not recall crowds, being shoved or pushed. I do not remember lines at the cash register or drivers snarling over parking spaces.

I had time to mull, to ponder, to weigh each of my purchases. I wasn’t obsessed with “the getting,” more than “the thing that was got.” Every gift was given quite serious, but not necessarily lengthy, thought. And I knew it was right when it bypassed my head and rammed straight into my heart. I knew, then, it would be just the right gift to be found under the tree on Christmas morning. For perfect presents have that quality of rightness, that specialness; they seem to conjure up Christmas morning feelings long after the day is done and the tree has been taken down.

Perhaps that is why it has been so long since I have enjoyed Christmas shopping. I have missed that feeling of rightness. My shopping list seems filled with brand names learned on Saturday morning television or Pinterest boards. I no longer shop on pure impulse, fueled by happiness and expectation. I have lost that lightness of step; now I am weighed down with the wants and desires of others (not that I have such a needy bunch but I do want to give them something they will like). Christmas shopping has become not something I want to do, but something I must get done.

When I was young and without worries, schedules, and parking problems, I knew how to shop. I would wander in and out of the  stores while the day darkened and the evening began to glisten with Christmas decorations and automobile lights. Some Christmases I would step out of a store just as it began to snow on shoppers and people going home. I would meet my mother at the corner of the dime store; she would pull up in the car and I would bundle in with bags and packages. And I always was amazed that she was never curious about the packages, never wanted to know which one of them was for her.

I used to think, riding home, that she didn’t want to spoil the surprise, and that may have been some of it. But, I think now, it was more likely that she had her mind on other things—shopping lists and parking spaces and schedules.

___________________________

How is your shopping experience going this year? Leave a comment and share it with us.

For a short story in the tradition of National Lampoon’s Christmas Vacation, check out “Christmas Unplugged.” And have a happy and well-lit holiday.

___________________________

This post is part of the Meet the Family Blog Hop. We all have festive traditions, memories, stories, recipes, hopes, and wishes that we share within our families. This hop is all about celebrating family and festivities, both in real life and in fiction! The host of this blog hop is Terri Giuliano Long.

Several writers are blogging about their holiday memories and experiences. Get in the holiday spirit! We will be blogging from December 10-13. Stop by our sites. You’ll find the entire list here. Please take a moment to read a few posts and comment. We love hearing from you. Have a fabulous holiday.



May 142012
 

Book of Mercy was a finalist in the 22nd Annual Midwest Book Awards, which were announced on May 9 in Bloomington, MN.

Is this a big deal?

I interviewed Antigone Brown, the main character in Book of Mercy, about her view of this momentous event. She is a mother-to-be who stands up to the book banners in her small North Carolina town, even though she can’t read.

Me: So Antigone how are you feeling about this nomination?

Antigone: They like me. They REALLY like me.

Me: Yeah, it was cool to be nominated. Publishers from 12 Midwestern states submitted 362 entries in 50 categories in this year’s competition.

Antigone: That many? Well, it’s validation. [Lowers voice.] After all, this was an indie (self-published) book.

Me: Why do you need validation?

Antigone: In the fiction world, as a female lead character, everybody is comparing you to either Scarlet O’Hara or Katniss Everdeen.

Me: Really? I had no idea.

Antigone: Yes. I only take on a group of highly influential women removing “undesirable” books from the school library . . .

Me: And don’t forget the pie thrower.

Antigone: How could I? I’m still washing that banana cream out of my clothes. But Scarlet in Gone with the Wind faced down the Union Army, and Katniss in The Hunger Games outmaneuvered mutant killer wasps. Tough competition.

Me: Personally, I hate contests.

Antigone: I’m with you. But we live in a world consumed by contests, from sports to American Idol and the Academy Awards.

Me: Still, I’m sorry I didn’t pit you against hordes of fighting men or an evil empire.

Antigone: Irene (the leader of the censors) was evil enough.

Me: Cheer up. You have a secret library. I doubt Scarlet ever read a book, and Katniss was too busy trying to feed her family.

Antigone: Yes. Bookhenge. Nice name for a library, by the way. But back to all these contests. I’m beginning to wonder what my child will be compared to.

Me: You’re always worrying about that baby.

Antigone: Of course. What’s a parent to do?

Me: You have many agonizing years ahead of you. There will be school recitals and pageants and spelling bees.

Antigone [shudders]: Kids called me a loser because I had trouble reading. I don’t want that for my child. I don’t see why we have to make comparisons at all.

Me: Because if you lose, it is supposed to make you try harder the next time.

Antigone: You mean, in the next book, you’ll try to write a better me?

Me: There is no better you. I will write a different you.

Antigone: Make her skinnier. She’ll like that.

The Midwest Book Awards are sponsored by the Midwest Independent Publishers Association.

________________

If you enjoyed this post, please subscribe to this blog, make a comment, or check out Book of Mercy. It would make Antigone happy, but please don’t compare her to Scarlet or Katniss. She gets touchy about those folks.

Apr 092012
 

I used to hate taxes.

It’s true. Every year around tax time, I would search the real estate ads in The New York Times for a small, used island: “Fixer upper. All you need is a well, a small power plant, a road grader, and a garbage collection truck, and you’ve got paradise. Excellent for the independent family. Biological observation galore. Views. Curtains and bug spray not included.”

Then one day, there it was. My tropical tax-free haven. We immediately sold out, packed up, and moved in. I won’t pretend it was easy, but we come from hearty Midwestern stock, and we did learn a heck of a lot about sailing on Minnesota’s 10,000 lakes.

I settled down on our island and began to write a 768-page treatise on exactly what was wrong with America’s economic system: “The rich get richer, while the poor get poorer . . .”

“Mom!” my daughter screamed from the outdoor shower. “There’s no water again. I simply must wash my hair every day.” I tapped a line, jiggled a bucket, handed her the Vidal Sassoon, and headed back to my computer.

“The temptation of tax evasion is not new,” I typed. “Since Biblical times, a visit by the tax collector has brought on the urge to hit the road. We have always wanted services but growled about paying for them.”

My daughter entered my office, drying her hair and mumbling that someone has to fix the potholes on Ocean Drive. Apparently, she’d lost the front tire of her bicycle to a yawning crater. I retrieved the tire, shoveled some gravel into the abyss, passed my daughter the bicycle pump, and returned to my manifesto.

I continued: “We all vilify taxes. Yet, taxes are the ties that bind the human population. Would America even be America without taxes? What if England had said to the colonists: run along, settle the place, and send a postcard when you can?”

I stopped. Was that my daughter strolling down the path, scantily clad in a camouflage bikini? I stuck my head out the window and yelled, “Where are you going dressed like that?”

“To the Occupy Island protest,” my daughter said, “and, by the way, I’m moving to the other side of the island. The service here is the pits. I don’t see why I have to pay my hard-earned coconuts for this. We need coconut collection reform. And, why does my sister pay fewer coconuts than I do?”

“Because you have more coconuts than she does. You can afford to give more to the island than she can. It’s a privilege.”

My daughter bunched a fist on her hip. “So I’m being penalized for being a better coconut tree climber.”

I quoted Benjamin Franklin to her: “Our constitution is in actual operation, everything appears to promise that it will last, but in this world nothing is certain but death and taxes.”

“Isn’t he the guy with the kite?” My daughter frowned.

“Look,” I said, “coconuts are a part of life. If you didn’t have coconuts, you wouldn’t have to pay coconut tax.”

Mar 262012
 

A little penguin named Tango and a banned book have created an uproar in Rochester, MN.

Rochester is the home of the Mayo Clinic, the facility patients come to from all over the world to get answers to tough medical questions. Here is where you hope someone will bring information into the light, not hide it. And yet in a recent move, Rochester School Superintendent Michael Muñoz and two school board members decided to do just that: They went against school policy and pulled a book from the shelves of Gibbs Elementary School after a parent complained. The book was And Tango Makes Three, a tale of two male penguins that hatch and raise a baby chick together.

This is not Tango‘s first trip to the rodeo. It has been on the American Library Association’s banned books list since it came out in 2005, usually in the number one spot. Critics contend that it endorses a homosexual lifestyle. As the book says, “She [Tango] was the very first penguin to have two daddies.”

This is a true story. Authors Justin Richardson and Peter Parnell could have included Tango’s much-publicized life in a nonfiction book about animals. Instead, they chose to write a children’s book about a most unusual penguin family.

Tango’s real family lives in the Central Park Zoo in New York. Roy and Silo are a pair of boy chinstrap penguins who prefer each other’s company to that of the girl penguins. The zookeeper noticed how Roy and Silo bowed and sang to each other, made a nice nest, and even rolled an egg-shaped rock into the nest, sitting on it for hours in the hopes of  “hatching” it.

Roy and Silo wanted a family.

When another penguin couple at the zoo produced two fertile eggs, the zookeeper gave one of them to Roy and Silo. After all, twins take work, and the odds of having two fertile penguin eggs raised to adulthood by one couple are slim. Roy and Silo knew “just what to do,” the zookeeper said. They kept the egg warm, turning it over and over so all sides would benefit, until their daughter Tango arrived. Tango’s fathers fed her, sang to her, and snuggled her warm at night. They made sure she knew she was wanted.

If we allow books like Tango to be banned because they make one person uncomfortable, we are giving in to tyranny. We are permitting someone else to control where we get our ideas, and Tango presents some brilliant ones about loving parenting and creating strong families (no matter what their makeup). It has received several national awards for good reason.

I admit I grow impatient with parents who claim censorship is needed to protect our children. I say the solution to this is simple: you control your child’s reading list, and I’ll control mine. Censorship is for cowards. If you want to provide gutsy and meaningful parenting, read Tango with your children and talk about why you do or don’t agree with the worldview it presents.

In Rochester, Tango‘s story was indeed tangled. It was first challenged in the fall of 2011. According to school district policy, it was sent for review to the district’s Committee for Reconsideration of Resources, which voted on November 15 to keep the book in its media collection. When the parent appealed again, Superintendent Muñoz and cohorts decided to ignore that decision and ban the book anyway. On March 19, after a packed school board meeting, Muñoz apologized and said the book would be returned to the library. The next step, if the parent wants to continue, would be to appeal to the entire school board during a public hearing.

I hope Tango is safe and sound in Rochester. In the recent standing-room-only meeting where not one person spoke against the book, Mayor Ardell Brede held a sign proclaiming Rochester as an “inclusive community.”

Like poet Carl Sandburg, I believe “inclusive” to be one of my favorite words. It doesn’t leave much room for hiding; it drags censorship out of the dark where the real dance begins in a free society.  

___________

For another look at censorship and parenting, check out Book of Mercy.

To hear a reading of And Tango Makes Three:
 

 

Nov 212011
 

It is easy to be a yogi in a cave in the Himalayas. Ascetics don’t realize how good they have it. They don’t have to worry about how to make the next college payment or tolerate telemarketers at dinner. No one cuts them off in traffic or expects them to put their world on hold for the Super Bowl.

I think it is especially difficult to be both a mother and a yogi. It’s the whole detachment thing. Mothers who tie themselves to other humans with that most intimate of tethers, the umbilical cord, can’t just cut loose the people, concerns, and joys in their lives. It’s a snap to detach in the bowels of a mountain. But just try it when your ailing nineteen-year-old calls from some under-staffed, low-tech hospital in a Third World country thousands of miles away. Or when your other daughter, the cheerful one, is crying her heart out, right there on your shoulder, over some loser who didn’t call.

To the yogi, even-mindedness is everything. We search for balance in mind, body, and spirit. We flow through poses meant to make us strong and centered—and presumably able to handle with equanimity the day the washer overflows and the cat barfs in front of guests and the sturdy oak shading your car falls like a giant flyswatter.

I meditate and practice asanas and read yogic texts—and I still fall apart in the midst of calamity. I still burn with anger and sink into depression. It is quite obvious. I am an inept yogi.

I don’t look like a yogi. I have the kind of shape that runs screaming from a unitard. I have fat cells as old as my children.

I don’t eat like a yogi either. Although I avoid most red meat, I still have occasional moments when bliss comes as a burger and fries. Vegetables are still my enemy, and vegetarianism is just an excuse to eat bread. Some days I wonder why I even unroll the yoga mat.

And then something unusual will happen and I will discover a tiny corner of yogi in me. Maybe I’ll be packed in a shop with all the other Christmas shoppers, clutching a paper in my hand, and waiting for the clerk to call my number. The woman next to me is transferring a fractious baby from one hip to another. I notice her number is higher than mine. And before I even realize what I’m doing, I offer to trade numbers. She declines, but I see the hope in her eyes and insist. And as the trade is made, the moment our fingers touch, a wave of calm and patience swamps me.

And then there was the time my cat was feeling poorly and I rushed her to the vet, only brief hours before I was due to drive halfway across the country. I thought the vet would simply give me some pills, the administration of which I could pawn off on the pet-sitter. But the vet said, no, my cat was dying from the advanced stages of renal failure. I had a choice: let her suffer or put her under.

I have had to put pets to sleep before. But this time, yogi mind reared its head and I was filled with ethical issues. Grief and sorrow mixed with the confusion of karma. Ahimsa is the yogic concept of:  harm no being or creature. My rational husband assured me it was the right thing to do. (I’d even consulted with him on the cell phone before holding Eclipse the cat for the last time, and he’d said: do it; make it merciful.) Yet I still cry for Eclipse sometimes.

Now, as a yogi, I don’t assume every good snake is a dead snake. When a spider invites itself into my shower, I don’t automatically reach for a shoe. I call for my husband to capture the creature and release it outside. Although it is a challenge, I try to refrain from glaring at impatient and rude people who shout in cell phones in public places.

As I said, being a yogi isn’t easy, especially in the wireless age, but then maybe it isn’t supposed to be.

Oct 162011
 

In August 1999, I put my daughter on a plane for Ecuador and settled down to wait. I had heard all the public relations about study abroad: how my daughter would never be the same after a semester as a foreigner. But I liked her the way she was before she left, I tell my husband, with a sniffle. He takes the exit out of the airport and gives my leg a comforting pat.

Gallivanting all over the world (otherwise known as “broadening”) is almost a requirement in raising a child in today’s global society. Corporate recruiters look for candidates who are sensitive to other cultures and savvy about political issues. Bilingual and multilingual skills translate into bonuses. Recognizing the value of the study abroad experience, however, doesn’t make it go down any easier for those left behind—parents, siblings, grandparents, roommates, lovers, pets.

So What Do We Do as We Wait?

My routine—one followed even on Sundays and holidays—quickly evolved. Each morning I checked the weather page in the newspaper to find out how the weather was in my daughter’s corner of the world. In Quito, Ecuador, situated within kissing distance of the equator, temperatures averaged in the sixties and seventies from August through December—the rainy season. It sounded like paradise with an umbrella, but I wasn’t to be fooled. No matter how perfect the weather where your child resides, you wonder what clothes and accessories he or she has on hand to reply to the elements: rain gear, hat, sun block, mosquito netting.

After the weather check, I turned to the international pages for catastrophic news: floods, blizzards, hurricanes, rebellions, political coups, or tribal uprisings. Of course, something or someone will be on the rampage near your child—you just know it. In my case, it was volcanoes. In Ecuador, a country smaller than Nevada, there are thirty volcanoes in two mountain ranges. The area is affectionately called the Avenue of the Volcanoes. Although most of Ecuador’s volcanoes are extinct, two bad boys flexed their muscles while my daughter was there: Tungurahua, which caused the evacuation of whole villages and the abandonment of businesses and crops, and Guagua Pichincha, which belched plumes of ash into the sky and sent everyone near Quito hunting for protective masks.

After breakfast, and my digestion of the news, I headed downstairs to gather my e-mail. On a good day, a message from Ecuador was waiting. To accomplish this feat, my daughter had ridden on a bus for two hours to a nearby major city, eluded the pickpockets, and found a cybercafe with a working Internet connection. Often the e-mails were short and reassuring: “The Quito airport has been closed for six days due to the volcano. Don’t worry. So far the ash showers are not bothering my asthma. I doubt the volcano will have an impact on my case of food poisoning.”

Occasionally the waiting was interrupted by a letter, written a month ago, perhaps amid a cloud of butterflies in the rain forest or huddled wet to the bone on a dirt floor. These communiqués expressed weeks-old feelings, fears, joys, and frustrations. You don’t know whether to be relieved or to call the American consul. Even better than a letter was a telephone call. At first, you can’t believe that the voice so far away is your baby and you feel like weeping, but at $2 a minute, you contain yourself. These calls are invariably bittersweet; your child is alternately enchanted by new experiences and yearning for familiar ones. Homesickness crackles between the words and the inevitable pauses of international telecommunications. Excitement sings along the wires.

These calls are never long enough and often inadequate—especially when your child opens by announcing that she is calling from the hospital but you’re not to worry.

“The hospital staff thinks the dysentery is under control,” my daughter says, and I imagine my firstborn alone in a strange hospital ward at the mercy of Third World medicine men and women.

“Is the hospital clean?” I ask.

“It looks okay to me,” she says. This from the daughter who hasn’t felt a hot shower in eight weeks.

“Can you understand the doctors and nurses?”

“Sometimes.”

What Took You So Long

We wait for soldiers to return from war and for the butcher to call our number at the meat counter. Teachers wait for understanding to flicker and shine in the eyes of students. Mothers wait for babies to be born. Children wait for St. Nick to squeeze down a chimney and step over the gas logs.

Does anyone become good at waiting? I am told that waiting teaches patience and humility, but then it also inspires road rage.

I’ve come to understand that you endure waiting by simply doing it and not thinking for too long at any one time about that for which you wait—that child who is dodging malaria-carrying mosquitoes in the rain forest or drinking espressos in a Parisienne café or cajoling a camel across the desert. That child, who you remember as being incapable of picking up her own socks, is now doing everything without you, and she is managing quite well, making mistakes and discovering strengths. In fact, she is laundering her Gap shirts by slapping them on a rock—something you can’t imagine doing.

Waiting is about letting go a little bit at a time, e-mail by e-mail, letter by letter. We can go into withdrawal and take to our beds or we can discover some strengths of our own. And when the plane touches down and she walks into your arms, you can’t help but notice that there’s a confidence to her stride, a gutsiness that she wears like an expensive perfume. Suddenly, you are in awe of what she has become—the woman you always wanted her to be.

Thoughts? When have you had to let go? How did you handle it?

Oct 042011
 

My daughter hates birds. Except for Tippi Hedren after being cooped up for months on a shoot with spooky Alfred Hitchcock, I don’t understand someone taking such a dislike to birds. “It’s their knees,” she says. “They bend backwards. Gross.”

 

I, on the other hand, am intrigued by any creature that effortlessly runs, swims, or flies. It seems you never see a gazelle with arthritic knees or a klutzy sunfish or an eagle with a fear of heights. Gracefulness, that ability to move seamlessly through one’s environment, simply amazes me.

 

Oh, I’ll admit nature can be a pain. For weeks I entertained murderous thoughts about a woodpecker that enjoyed early morning jackhammering on the wall by my bed. A friend suggested that I place fake snakes on the side of the house to scare off the woodpecker, a trick similar to mounting phony owls on the runways of airports. But I didn’t think nailing rubber reptiles to the wood siding was going to enhance my property value.

 

And I have been known, while camping, to shout for a gun in the middle of the night as I tossed and turned in my sleeping bag, finding every rock on the ground, while a whippoorwill in a nearby tree called and called and called.

 

Yet despite these nuisances, I keep seeking nature out. Since moving from North Carolina to Minnesota, I have taken to the trails that crisscross the prairie. I never tire of seeing the white egret standing on the edge of the pond. And if the Canada geese are noisy so are the airplanes.

 

One of my first weekend trips after I arrived was to the Mississippi River where on an island there was a colony of great blue heron or as we birding insiders call them: GBHs. GBHs are cool creatures, winging overhead their long legs dangling behind them, but they are something else playing house in gargantuan nests atop the cottonwoods. A naturalist told me that every year they count the GBHs in Minnesota. It is not a job for the timid. The census takers wear goggles and rain gear because apparently the GBHs do not take kindly to being counted and express their displeasure by either pecking or vomiting on the GBH counter.

 

My husband, who was raised in Minnesota, has childhood memories of loons on crystal lakes. Even though we live in suburbia, he has two pairs of binoculars at the ready at all times. This is not as crazy as it sounds. When visiting Connemara, the North Carolina mountain home of Carl Sandburg, I noticed a pair of binoculars on the dining room table. There was a line of bird feeders outside the dining room windows. Apparently, it was not unusual for Carl to throw down his grilled cheese in the middle of lunch, grab the spyglasses, and scope out the hummingbirds.

 

Of course, it does not do to become too attached to anything in nature. Easy come, easy go is the natural law. Once I was watching a little boy tossing stale bread to some ducks in a small lake in North Carolina. It was spring, and the cuddly, fuzzy baby ducks simply melted your heart. We were laughing at the ducks’ antics when a big turtle rose out of the water and snapped off the head of one of the baby ducks. The traumatized child ran screaming to his mother. Suddenly, I wanted my mother, too.

 

After reading any news on the Timberwolves (the basketball team, not the critters) and the latest terrorist attacks, I usually turn to the Variety section of the paper. There in the “Did You Know?” column is all kinds of useful information. Sometimes even stuff about birds. One morning after reading the paper, I had to call my daughter. I’d just read that those knobs on the long, pencil-thin legs of flamingos were not knees. They were ankles. The knees of flamingos are actually hidden under their feathers.

 

“So, what you’re saying is this bird has ankles half way up its legs,” my daughter said. “That’s still gross.”

 

Sep 222011
 

I had been stumbling around in the plot of a book I was writing for some time. I knew the protagonist couldn’t read and that books were disappearing. I was going for some kind of Alice Hoffman magical realism thing. Perhaps with a little humor since my book’s working title was “Too Dark to Read,” after the Groucho Marx quote: “Outside a dog, a book is man’s best friend. Inside a dog, it’s too dark to read.” But then in 1996, my daughter came through the door, crying, “Mom, they’re banning books!”

My daughter was a junior and an IB student in a North Carolina high school. She had a mean forehand and a voracious love for books, including the book in question, The Old Gringo by Carlos Fuentes. Fuentes is recognized as one of the most influential writers in Latin America. In fact, in 2006, he received the Four Freedoms Award for Freedom of Speech and Expression. Ironic, I know.

My first response was to sit down, read the book, and discuss it with my daughter. It is the story of celebrated American writer and journalist Ambrose Bierce, who mysteriously disapeared in Mexico during its civil war. Fuentes imagines the fate of Bierce among Pancho Villa’s troops in a tale that examines “the borders between men and women, dreams and reality, Mexico and the U.S,” as Publishers Weekly put it.

What the censors in our town (parents of one of the students) objected to were explicit scenes between a young Mexican revolutionary and the American teacher, who falls in love with him. I had no problem with my 17-year-old daughter reading those scenes. But then I’ve never denied my daughter a book she wanted to read.

After an intense public meeting and a review by committee, The Old Gringo eventually was returned to the shelf and the IB curriculum. But in the process, my daughter’s English teacher, a favorite of many of the kids, decided to move on, perhaps to a place where teachers didn’t receive hate mail.

This incident had a huge impact on the direction of my book. Book banning in fictitious Mercy, North Carolina, became the conflict, and Antigone Brown, the woman who fights the censors, ponders the same questions I had as I wrote letters in protest of the removal of The Old Gringo.

All too often, censorship is a parental issue. As Antigone says in Book of Mercy, “I want to protect my child from the world. But I also want to protect the world for my child.”

What I learned in writing this book and in raising my daughter is that books can never be allowed to disappear from the shelves without a squeak. We must say something; explode the discussion in letters, e-mails, tweets, and public meetings. We must never let censorship dissolve into the dark.

According to the American Library Association, on average about five hundred books are challenged every year in the United States—and those are just the ones we know about. Some would say this is horrible. But I think if we didn’t have a way to challenge the actions of others, we wouldn’t be truly free.

So I accept that book challenges are necessary, but I also am happy when they fail.

Book of Mercy, a story about a woman who faces her greatest fear to save a town’s books, is available in paperback and on Kindle. Read more about Book of Mercy or check out an excerpt.

Jun 102011
 

It is a dark day when a national newspaper like the Wall Street Journal advocates censorship for the good of the kids. In a June 4, 2011 article, WSJ complained about the “darkness” in young adult (YA) fiction these days. It noted that far too often young readers find themselves ”surrounded by images not of joy or beauty but of damage, brutality and losses of the most horrendous kinds.”

It notes parents should be allowed to guide what young people read—no argument there as long as said parents keep their hands off MY children’s reading list. But WSJ goes on: ”In the book trade, this is known as ‘banning’. In the parenting trade, however, we call this ‘judgment’ or ‘taste’.”

Linda Holmes, a blogger for NPR, brings up an excellent point when she wonders who parents are trying to protect by imposing their “guidance” on someone else. She writes:

“Banning is banning, not guidance, and if the suggestion is that that’s the parenting role, it has to be done … regretfully, I think. Even for parents acting with regard to their own kids, the act of one human being actually preventing another human being from reading a book is a grave decision. Obviously, not everything is appropriate for every audience — nobody is suggesting you give Twilight to your seven-year-old. (Or, really, to anyone, although that’s more because of the quality of the writing than because the themes are too dark.) But stopping — actually stopping — a YA reader from picking up a particular book because it describes behavior you don’t want him to emulate potentially cuts him off from something that might reach him in exchange for … nothing, really, except your own comfort level.”

Will children emulate the behaviors they read about—suicide, cursing, having sex, self-mutilation, bullying, being abusive, rape? Who knows? I have to believe that one scene of a girl cutting herself or a boy beating up another one for his lunch money will not undo the years of parenting I have invested in raising loving and caring individuals with healthy self-esteems.

No one reads books in a vacuum. We bring to each book our own values and beliefs, and we slide the book’s values into our own to see how they fit. We reject what doesn’t fit and enjoy what does.

I read YA fiction. I love its energy, creativity, and moral system. I read the Harry Potter books and don’t see the evils of magic. I see children learning about courage and unbreakable friendships, about being different and surviving. I read Suzanne Collins’ The Hunger Games series and see brutality unmasked and manipulation thwarted. These are the values I want my children to think about and, perhaps, adopt.

U.S. General William Westmoreland said, “Without censorship, things can get terribly confused in the public mind.”  I would argue just the opposite. With censorship, things can get terribly muddled in the mind of a child.

Kids already know that ugliness exists in the world. Through books, they discover it’s how you handle the ugliness that counts.